I've been going round and round with this for a while now. In the tread you linked the guy was trying to compare to a 4:11 rear end when impellers totally don't work that way. Comparing a C to an AA, the AA has a harder bite on the water and requires more power to turn a given RPM than a C, meaning at 5,000 RPM an AA will compress more water than a C, BUT the velocity will be close to the same on both which allows lower horsepower to turn that C impeller at the given 5,000 rpm. But without the volume of water the AA can push with more power, the holeshot suffers.
My opinion, calculate your horsepower as close as possible and use an impeller chart to keep your motor in the RPM you want it to operate in. Our cruiser boats could haul A$$ and turn the crap out of a B impeller, but I don't want to turn my motor that fast. I'm estimating 530-550 horsepower out of my aluminum head motor. Wanting to keep my RPM in the 5,000 area I should get an AA according to the charts. We'll see if that holds true, but my A impeller will be standing by..
Finally, word on the street is the Agressor impellers are worth one size bigger. An Agressor A compares to a Berkeley AA.